Understanding Reasonable Compensation: A Guide for S-Corp Owners

Chris Coggins • August 12, 2023

Navigating Reasonable Compensation: A Guide for Fellow S-Corp Owners

We understand the intricate landscape of running an S-Corp, and one critical aspect that demands attention is Reasonable Compensation. As experts in financial management and advisors to numerous S-Corp entities, we're here to shed light on this essential topic.


Grasping Reasonable Compensation Essentials

  1. Foundational Requirement: It's important to note that every shareholder-employee within an S-Corp is legally obliged to provide themselves with a reasonable salary, known as Reasonable Compensation. This is achieved through the issuance of a W-2 form, a step that takes precedence over any distributions.
  2. Annual Assessment: We strongly recommend an annual Reasonable Compensation assessment. This can be carried out using one of the three IRS-endorsed methodologies, ensuring compliance and accuracy.
  3. Meticulous Record-Keeping: Keeping meticulous records of supporting documents pertaining to your calculated Reasonable Compensation figure is paramount. This practice not only ensures compliance but also simplifies the process come tax season.


Balancing S-Corp Benefits and Responsibilities

The advantages of S-Corp status are undeniable, but let's not overlook the corresponding responsibilities:

  • Wage Allocation: Prioritizing the allocation of reasonable wages (Reasonable Compensation) via the appropriate W-2 form for shareholder-employees is a foundational step preceding any distributions.
  • Specialized Tax Return: Managing an additional tax return specifically for the S-Corp is a necessary responsibility.
  • State Considerations: Depending on your state, there might be supplemental fees associated with your S-Corp status.
  • Becoming an S-Corp: Transitioning into an S-Corp might involve filing fees and procedural considerations.


Consultation for Informed Decisions

Before embarking on significant decisions, it's imperative to tap into the expertise of dedicated accounting professionals. As a recommendation tailored to your unique needs, consider reaching out to Outsourced CFO Solutions, Inc. Our team has a proven track record of guiding S-Corp owners through intricate financial terrain.


Demystifying Reasonable Compensation

For many S-Corp proprietors, grappling with Reasonable Compensation is a continuous journey. The IRS defines Reasonable Compensation as: the payment that would typically be made for comparable services within similar enterprises and under similar circumstances. ~ IRS Code: Section 162-7(b)(3)

In simpler terms, it's akin to asking: "What would be a justifiable compensation for an identical role, held by a non-owner in a separate employment context, within a similar company?"


Key Points to Embrace:

  • Value-Centric Approach: Reasonable Compensation is rooted in the value of services provided, unrelated to profits or distributions.
  • Wage Priority: Ensure that wages (Reasonable Compensation) are processed prior to distributions, and that they're accurately documented through W-2 forms.
  • Wage vs. Distribution: While opting for wages without distributions is feasible, the reverse is not true.
  • Flexibility in Compensation: If your current circumstances allow, you have the flexibility to forgo immediate Reasonable Compensation, with the option to catch up in subsequent years.


Informed Decisions through Expertise


The journey of S-Corp ownership demands strategic decisions. At Outsourced CFO Solutions, our personalized guidance and support are designed to enhance your S-Corp experience, ensuring compliance, informed choices, and financial success.  If you have questions about S-Corp ownership we can help. Contact Outsourced CFO Solutions, Inc. today.

Wrapping up the year. Outsoured CFO Solutions, Roseville, CA
By Chris Coggins December 10, 2025
December is a unique month for small business owners. It’s full of celebrations, end-of-year deadlines, and the odd mix of excitement and exhaustion. You’re juggling client gifts, last-minute sales, employee bonuses, and financial records.
Happy Thanksgiving, Outsourced CFO Solutions, Roseville, CA
By Chris Coggins November 12, 2025
Running a small business isn’t for the faint of heart. You’re the CEO, the customer service team, the janitor, and sometimes the IT department all rolled into one. And then there are taxes, those mysterious, ever-changing rules that can make even the bravest entrepreneur want to hide under the Thanksgiving table.
Halloween Red Moon with Cat
By Chris Coggins October 14, 2025
Discover the spooky tax mistakes that haunt small business owners—and learn how to avoid them with smart planning before they cost you.